The Groove 234 - Six Lessons Museums Can Teach You About Art Collecting
Welcome to the 234th issue of The Groove.
I am Maria Brito, an art advisor, curator, and author based in New York City.
If you haven’t done so, please subscribe here, to get The Groove in your inbox for free every Tuesday.
SIX LESSONS MUSEUMS CAN TEACH YOU ABOUT ART COLLECTING
Julie Mehretu, “Stadia II”, 2004. Ink and acrylic on canvas. Collection of the Carnegie Museum of Art, Pittsburgh.
When you hear “museum-quality,” what comes to mind?
A safe blue-chip? A mega price tag? A massive painting you can’t even fit in your living room?
Here’s the truth: most people misunderstand what museum-quality really means, and they misunderstand how museums buy.
And that’s a shame, because some of the smartest lessons for private collectors come from watching institutional ones.
This week I want to lay out what buying like a museum actually means. What they do well. What they get wrong. And how you can use their best moves to build a collection that actually matters.
What Museums Actually Buy (and Why)
Museums don’t buy for speculation.
They don’t flip. They don’t chase Instagram trends. They don’t care what art consultants are shilling this month.
They buy for legacy.
They think in decades. Centuries. They’re asking: What tells the story of our time? What completes or complicates the narrative we’re trying to hold?
That’s why they often buy what the market ignores. They’ll pursue works that are underappreciated, experimental, even unfashionable - because they see historical value before the price catches up.
Lesson 1: Narratives Over Trends
Collectors tend to get tripped up by the shiny new thing.
I’ve seen it a hundred times: they’re seduced by hype cycles, by auction prices that have outpaced reason, by art fair booths designed to induce FOMO.
World-class museums, on the other hand, build with a thesis.
They’re not buying what’s hot. They’re buying what fits. What tells a story.
Take the Tate Modern’s purchase of Lubaina Himid’s “Freedom and Change” in 2019. Himid won the Turner Prize in 2017, but she had spent decades under-recognized in the mainstream market. The Tate didn’t buy her work because it was suddenly “hot,” but because they recognized its place in British cultural history and the broader narrative of Black British art.
Buying like a museum means asking:
• How does this piece fit the narrative of my collection?
• Does it add depth, nuance, complexity?
• Am I buying it because I want it, or because I’m afraid someone else will get it?
Lesson 2: Historical Context Is Non-Negotiable
You know what museums don’t do? Buy blindly.
Every acquisition is researched to death. Provenance, exhibition history, condition, scholarship: they know exactly what they’re getting.
For example, in 2015 the Metropolitan Museum of Art bought Kerry James Marshall’s 2014 “Untitled (Studio),” on primary market through the artist’s gallery, David Zwirner. Even at a moment when his market was warming, they recognized his critical importance to American art history. It wasn’t a bargain, but The Met recognized it was then or never. In 2016, Marshall’s exuberant retrospective “Mastry” at the same museum swept audiences off their feet, triggered auction records, and made his work impossible to find. (And if found, even more impossible to afford.)
The Met didn’t use the market to confirm their choice. They understood where the artist fit.
If you want to buy like a museum, you need to understand not just what you’re buying, but why it matters.
Lesson 3: Buy Before the Crowd Catches Up
Museums aren’t always first, let’s be honest.
But when they’re good, they buy before the market explodes.
In 2008, the Whitney Museum acquired Mark Bradford’s “Bread and Circuses” (2007) for a fraction of what his large-scale works now command. At the time, Bradford was moving up, but not yet a market darling.
Museums don’t wait for an auction record, they often help create it.
Collectors who want real value that’s not just financial, but cultural, should aim to do the same.
Lesson 4: Build Relationships
Museums don’t just buy art. They build ecosystems.
They cultivate artists. Commission new work. Support research. Maintain archives.
Consider the Carnegie Museum of Art in Pittsburgh. They championed Julie Mehretu in the early 2000s, acquiring “Stadia II” (2004), one of her masterpieces, soon after it was made. That early institutional support helped define her career.
Great private collectors do the same, on their own scale.
• Stay close to artists and galleries.
• Support work that might not be immediately “sellable.”
• Invest in relationships that grant access to the best material.
Museums understand buying is just one part of being a cultural steward.
Lesson 5: Think Long-Term, Always
Museums don’t sell often. When they do, it’s deliberate.
They don’t panic because something is “out.” They hold because they know markets move in cycles.
That piece you’re tired of? The one you think is “over”? It might be the rediscovery of 2045.
If you want a museum-level collection, you have to resist the temptation to trade your vision for liquidity.
What Museums Get Wrong (And You Don’t Have To)
Let’s be fair: Museums can be slow. Political. Risk-averse.
They fight with committees. They hedge bets to keep donors happy.
You don’t have to.
You can move fast when you know. Be first. Take risks. Support what you believe in without twelve board votes.
You can buy like a collector with the eye of a curator and the freedom of a rogue.
Buy Like a Museum, Think Like an Artist
Buying like a museum doesn’t mean buying safe.
It means buying smart. Buying with vision. Buying with a sense of legacy.
Museums buy for history.
So should you.
Because if you do it right, your collection isn’t just your story. It’s the story of our time, told through your eyes.
If you want to talk about building that kind of collection, you know where to find me.